A dark grass field at the edge of a small town at night with distant emergency lights behind a tree line

Tennessee 25-Foot Buffer Law: Sixth Circuit Revives Press Suit

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit vacated and remanded the denial of a preliminary injunction against Tennessee's police buffer-zone law on November 10, 2026. The unpublished order in No. 26-5182 does not strike the law down and does not pause it. It sends the injunction request back to a federal judge in Nashville with an instruction to ask the question he skipped the first time: are the challengers likely to win?

For anyone who follows police work closely, this is the second half of a story that scanner owners already know from the radio side. Encryption removes the audio. A buffer law removes the visual. Both are attempts to control who can observe a police response, and this case is the live federal test of the second one.

The opinion and the Tennessee Lookout report of November 12 are both public.

What the Sixth Circuit actually decided

The panel was Chief Judge Raymond M. Kethledge, Senior Judge R. Guy Cole Jr. and Judge Andre B. Mathis. Their finding was procedural but consequential: the district court ruled on irreparable harm without first weighing the plaintiffs' likelihood of success on the merits, which the panel called "the most important one in First Amendment cases."

That is a sequencing error, not a merits ruling. The practical effect is that Judge William Campbell Jr. of the Middle District of Tennessee now has to run the full four-factor preliminary injunction analysis instead of resting on the harm prong alone. In February 2026 he had denied the injunction, finding the plaintiffs had not shown a particular situation where the law "impacted a reporter or anyone."

Their reporters routinely face a choice between defying a direct order of a police officer, with an attendant threat of criminal punishment for the reporters and their employers alike, or ceasing activity protected by the First Amendment.

What Tennessee's 25-foot law says

The statute is Tenn. Code Ann. § 39-16-612. The General Assembly passed it in May 2025, and it took effect in July 2025. It makes it a misdemeanor to come within 25 feet of an officer who is engaged in a traffic stop, an active crime-scene investigation, or an ongoing and immediate threat to public safety, after being ordered to retreat. Penalties run up to six months and a $500 fine.

Note the trigger. The law does not ban standing near police work in general. It activates on a direct order from an officer in one of those three situations, which is why the standing argument in this case turned on what happens to a reporter who must choose between complying and continuing to record.

Why the panel found standing, and why that matters

Standing was the state's strongest defense, and it did not hold at this stage. The panel accepted that the coalition's reporters face a concrete dilemma each time an officer gives the order, and that the dilemma itself is the injury. If that reasoning survives the remand, the case proceeds on the merits rather than dying at the courthouse door.

The coalition is Gannett, Scripps Media, TEGNA, the Tennessee Lookout and the Nashville Banner, represented by Paul McAdoo and Grayson Clary of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press. The suit was filed in May 2025.

No injunction is in force right now

This is the part that gets lost in headlines about the appeal. Nothing in the November 10 order suspends the statute. Officers in Tennessee can still give the 25-foot order today, and violating it is still a misdemeanor.

The Tennessee Lookout reports that the Memphis Safe Task Force, a federal and state group, has invoked the law repeatedly to move observers back from traffic stops and arrests. A separate suit by the ACLU of Tennessee on behalf of four observers describes the same pattern. The law's sponsor, Republican Sen. Mark Pody of Lebanon, said during the session that it was meant to protect the work of law enforcement.

The pattern: Indiana and Louisiana

Tennessee is not the first state to try this. Similar 25-foot laws in Indiana and Louisiana were struck down after challenges by the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, in both cases on the breadth of discretion the law handed to officers. That history is why the Sixth Circuit's remand matters beyond Tennessee: it puts a third circuit-level look at the same statutory design.

Why a scanner owner should care

Listeners tend to treat access fights as somebody else's problem, usually a newsroom's. The mechanism is the same in both cases: a rule that makes observation harder, applied case by case, until the public record thins out.

A scanner tells you a pursuit started. A buffer law decides whether anyone can stand close enough to see how it ended. When departments pair encryption with scene restrictions, the only remaining public record is often the department's own press release, and that is written after the fact by the agency being described.

If your county still transmits in the clear, the audio is worth having while it lasts, and our guide to what survives police scanner encryption covers the states where the picture is mixed. For Tennessee specifically, a pre-programmed dual-band scanner will still pull the agencies that have not encrypted, and the public records route is the fallback for the ones that have. We covered the same two-front squeeze in Illinois, where bills force media access when police encrypt.

Hear your county’s traffic — tonight

Every scanner ships pre-programmed to your zip code. Open the box, turn it on, listen.

Shop Scanners →

FAQ

Did the Sixth Circuit strike down Tennessee's buffer law?

No. It vacated and remanded the denial of a preliminary injunction on November 10, 2026, which sends the request back to the district court for a full analysis. The statute remains in effect.

How far away must I stand under the law?

25 feet from an officer engaged in a traffic stop, an active crime-scene investigation or an ongoing immediate threat, after the officer orders you to retreat. The offense is a misdemeanor, with penalties up to six months and a $500 fine.

Is the law enforced while the lawsuit continues?

Yes. No injunction is in force, so agencies can still give the order. The Tennessee Lookout reports repeated use by the Memphis Safe Task Force.

Who is suing?

Gannett, Scripps Media, TEGNA, the Tennessee Lookout and the Nashville Banner, represented by the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press. The case returns to Judge William Campbell Jr. in the Middle District of Tennessee.

What happens in Indiana and Louisiana?

Their 25-foot buffer laws were struck down after challenges by the Reporters Committee, both on grounds tied to how much discretion the laws gave officers.

Does this affect police radio or scanner use?

Not directly. It affects what you can observe at a scene. The radio side is a separate fight over encryption, and the two together determine how much of a police response the public can still see or hear.

Bottom line: The Sixth Circuit reopened the case, not the street. Tennessee's 25-foot order is enforceable today, and the district court now has to weigh the First Amendment claim properly. Watch the remand docket for the injunction ruling, and read the opinion before citing the case.

Listen to your county tonight

Your scanner, pre-programmed to your zip code

Open the box, turn it on, listen. Your county’s frequencies are already loaded, tested, and backed by lifetime support.

  • ✓ Free US shipping
  • ✓ Programmed to your ZIP
  • ✓ Lifetime support
  • ✓ 30-day returns
Back to blog