Pennsylvania Ruling: Dispatch Audio Closed, CAD Timestamps Open
Share
A Pennsylvania Office of Open Records final determination issued on November 12, 2026 gives scanner listeners in the state a clear answer to a question that comes up every time a department goes dark: when the audio is closed, what can you still get? The answer is the clock. In Vernon Dwaine Robinson v. Delaware County (OOR Dkt. No. AP 2026-4002), the office ruled that the county could withhold its radio transmissions and its CAD event log under Section 708(b)(18) of the Right-to-Know Law, except for the time response log information inside that log, which must be released. The case was granted in part and denied in part. The full docket sheet is public.
That split matters more than it first looks. It separates two different kinds of evidence about a police response: the words officers said to each other, and the timestamps showing how long the public waited. Pennsylvania closes the first one. It did not close the second.
What the request actually asked for
The underlying request sought a batch of records tied to a single traffic stop, vehicle seizure and towing. Delaware County argued that no further responsive records existed, and the Office of Open Records accepted that part of the argument. The fight narrowed to two items the county did hold: the responsive radio transmissions and the CAD event log.
Both fell under the dispatch exemption. Only one of them was allowed to stay secret in full.
The exact wording of Section 708(b)(18), and where the seam is
The exemption is narrow in a way that most requests never exploit. Section 708(b)(18)(i) covers records or parts of records, except time response logs, pertaining to audio recordings, telephone or radio transmissions received by emergency dispatch personnel, including 911 recordings. Subparagraph (ii) adds a separate exception: the paragraph does not apply to a 911 recording, or a transcript of one, if an agency or a court determines that the public interest in disclosure outweighs the interest in nondisclosure.
Two words do the work here. "Except time response logs" is a carve-out written into the statute itself, not a balancing test a requester has to win. If a record is a time response log, the exemption simply does not reach it.
Why the CAD event log was only partly protected
The county tried to keep the CAD event log whole. It invoked Section 5399(a.1) of the Emergency Communication Services Act, which is the confidentiality provision for emergency communication services, and argued that the timestamps inside the log were covered there too.
The Office of Open Records found the county had failed to prove that any time response log information inside the CAD event log was made confidential by that section. That is the entire holding on this point: not that the log is public, but that the county did not carry its burden on the portion the RTKL already excludes from the exemption. The rest of the log stayed withheld.
The agency showed it was permitted to withhold the responsive radio transmissions and CAD Event Log, but for any time response log information contained therein, under Section 708(b)(18) of the RTKL.
What to request when a Pennsylvania feed goes encrypted
This is the practical takeaway, and it is short. When a department encrypts, do not spend your first request on audio. Ask for the log.
- Name the record, not the topic. Ask for the CAD event log, the incident report number, and the time response log information for a specific incident on a specific date. A request framed around "all records" invites a no-responsive-records answer, which is exactly what happened to the remainder of this request.
- Say the words "time response log" in the request. The carve-out is textual. Quote Section 708(b)(18)(i) and its "except time response logs" language so the agency cannot treat the whole log as a single exempt unit.
- Ask for timestamps as data. Dispatched time, en route time, arrival time, cleared time. Those fields are what proves a response gap, and they are the fields the OOR just ordered released.
- Watch the clock yourself. The docket shows the agency took a 30-day extension, and the request was then deemed denied before it reached a final determination. A deemed denial is still appealable, and it is often the fastest route to a ruling.
- Keep a 911 recording request separate. If a recording of the call itself exists, that is a different argument under subparagraph (ii), and mixing it into a CAD request muddies both.
None of this gets you the audio back. What it gets you is the timeline, and timelines are convertible: they become public accountability stories, they become comparisons between districts, and they are the raw material for arguing that a closed feed is hiding a service problem rather than protecting an investigation.
The 911 exception, and how rarely it wins
Subparagraph (ii) lets a 911 recording or transcript out when the public interest in disclosure outweighs the interest in nondisclosure. Read it carefully: the weighing is done by the agency or a court, not by the requester. That means the exception exists but is rarely self-executing. Where a caller's safety, a medical detail or an active investigation is in play, expect the agency to weigh against release and expect that weighing to be deferred to.
The cleaner path for most listeners remains the timestamps, because that route does not require anyone to rule in your favor on a balancing test.
Deadlines and what happens next
The determination is appealable to Commonwealth Court within 30 days, so the window on this particular case runs into mid-December 2026. Unless Delaware County appeals, the time response log portion of that CAD event log has to come out.
For everyone else in the state, the ruling is a template rather than a precedent that binds other agencies, but it is the kind of template that costs an agency money to fight. If your county has encrypted dispatch and you have a specific incident with a slow response, this is the request to send. If you want to keep hearing the traffic that is still in the clear in your area, the practical gear question is covered in our guide to what you can still hear under police scanner encryption. A pre-programmed handheld scanner covers the counties that have not gone dark, and the public records route above covers the ones that have.
Hear your county’s traffic — tonight
Every scanner ships pre-programmed to your zip code. Open the box, turn it on, listen.
FAQ
Is dispatch audio public in Pennsylvania?
No, not as a general matter. Section 708(b)(18) of the Right-to-Know Law exempts radio transmissions received by emergency dispatch personnel, and the OOR upheld that exemption for Delaware County in its November 12, 2026 determination.
What is a time response log?
It is the record of when a call came in and when units were dispatched, arrived and cleared. The RTKL exempts dispatch records "except time response logs," which means those timestamps sit outside the exemption.
Can I get the CAD event log from a Pennsylvania county?
You can get the time response log information inside it. In this case the county kept the rest of the log but failed to prove that the timestamps were confidential under Section 5399(a.1) of the Emergency Communication Services Act.
Does the 911 public interest exception apply often?
Rarely on its own. Section 708(b)(18)(ii) requires an agency or a court to find that public interest in disclosure outweighs nondisclosure before a 911 recording or transcript is released.
How long do I have to appeal an OOR determination?
30 days to Commonwealth Court, per the determination in this case. The agency side of the process also includes a 30-day extension to respond, which the county used here.
Does this ruling apply to other Pennsylvania counties?
It is not binding on them, but it is a published determination interpreting the same statute. Citing it in a request makes the same argument harder for another agency to dismiss.
Bottom line: Pennsylvania will close the audio, and it will not always close the clock. Request the time response log, quote the carve-out in Section 708(b)(18), and keep the request tied to one incident. The OOR docket sheet is the document to attach.
Listen to your county tonight
Your scanner, pre-programmed to your zip code
Open the box, turn it on, listen. Your county’s frequencies are already loaded, tested, and backed by lifetime support.
Baofeng UV-5R Mini
Our favorite everyday pick — tiny, dual-band, pre-programmed to your zip code.
Baofeng UV-5R (Black)
The classic entry point — reliable dual-band scanning at the best price.
Baofeng UV-5R Plus
More memory, more features — the value pick with extra headroom.
Baofeng K5 Plus Tri-Band
Tri-band coverage and 128 channels for serious listeners.
- ✓ Free US shipping
- ✓ Programmed to your ZIP
- ✓ Lifetime support
- ✓ 30-day returns